Annual Conference 2014 Wrap-Up



By Jackie Campbell

Against the backdrop of fishing nets and a dock, Bishop Thomas J. Bickerton and other speakers at the Western PA Annual Conference emphasized the need to be Drawn Deeper beneath surface issues and beyond ourselves to seek and follow God’s will in our lives.

In the opening worship, Bishop Bickerton used the story from John 4 of the Samaritan woman at the well to illustrate how Jesus reached out in love across traditional boundaries regardless of the cultural rules. Followers of Christ are called to do the same, he said, and must go deeper to find ways to do that.

The Bishop struck a sobering note in his State of the Church address when, in listing a series of challenges faced over the past year, he pointed to a rise in patterns of racist, sexist and discriminatory behavior in some congregations. Those exhibiting these behaviors are voicing their own opinions, "but that voice is not the voice of Jesus," the Bishop said. 

“Everyone is welcome in the fellowship of our church,” he added, “but these voices of racism and sexism are not welcome and must be confessed and transformed if we are to find our true voice of witness and ministry in this Annual Conference."

As the church faces difficult and divisive issues, its people are called to reflect God’s love and speak with the voice of Jesus, Bishop Bickerton said. “We have to draw deep into the well of God’s grace and draw deep into the heart of God.  The future of the church will depend not upon our humanly driven ideas...

“Can we all find a way to lay down our human agendas and opinions, no matter how convinced we are that they are right, and genuinely … open ourselves to what God would have us do and be?” he asked. “It is time for us to demonstrate to the world that different people who think differently can find ways to love one another in spite of our differences.”

In an attempt to do this, during a lunchtime session, the Bishop focused on Same Gender Ceremonies and Church Law, explaining differences in various sections of The Book of Discipline and the circumstances surrounding resolution of complaints filed against some clergy for officiating at same-sex unions.  He said the session would be the first in a series of discussions around Western PA aimed at determining how we can “preserve the unity of the church and be fully inclusive in the midst of our diversity?”

At the Laity Academy before the official start of the annual conference, Frank Schaefer, the Eastern PA pastor who was defrocked after officiating at the same sex marriage of his son, told his story in classes presented by the Reconciling Ministries Network. He was joined by Pittsburgh Theological Seminary Professor Steve Tuell, who described Biblical stories in which those who “broke the rules”, including Jesus, were favored by God.

As Bible Study leader at the annual conference, Dr. Joy Moore, an associate dean and assistant professor of preaching at Fuller Theological Seminary, emphasized the need to learn and tell the stories of the Bible, rather than using Google to find words that match our own ideas. In a session entitled Working with Words in a Visual Age, she said, “It is easy to pass through the Bible and weave together a scriptural witness to our preconceived notions.”  By not telling the sacred stories, we undermine the truth, she added.
Guest Preacher for the Conference was Bishop James King Jr. of the North Georgia Conference. He focused on the book of Acts, where God flows through Christ’s followers. Noting that every day presents a new opportunity to be more Christlike, he said people today are looking for a church that will bless them and meet their needs, rather than looking for a church where they can be a blessing. “Our way of blocking God is by focusing on ourselves,” he said. “In caring for ourselves beyond all measure, we block God.”  He urged members to let God flow through them.
At the commissioning service for new provisional elders, he emphasized the need to keep moving. “There is no place to pull over and park and say God is through with me now,” he said.  He also offered 8 Holy Habits to Keep Us Close to the Holy Spirit: Prayer, studying scripture, worship, hanging out with Christian friends, family time, moderate exercise, a healthy diet and taking a vacation moment.

A Joyful Conclusion

While the Conference opened with Bishop Bickerton stressing the importance of loving one another despite differences and heard about serious issues facing the church, it ended on a high, joyful note.

During the Sunday morning ordination service the Bishop said leaders need to bring joy back into our churches. Calling himself the official DJ for his Cabinet, he demonstrated by showing a video of Pharell Williams’ Oscar -nominated hit “Happy” and encouraged everyone to get on their feet and dance to the catchy tune. The joy was contagious.

At the service, eight new elders were ordained and two associate members received into full membership. Ten provisional elders were commissioned the previous morning.

Earlier in the conference, the ministries of 22 retiring clergy members, representing 669 years of service, were celebrated, Retirees included: Jaime Potter Alvarez, Clara W. Belloit, Jerry B. Belloit, David W. Bunnell, Dongsam Cho, James M. Eaton, Allen O. Grimm III, Ronald E. Fleming, Ronald R. Hoellein,Deryl K. Larsen, Frederick H. Leasure, James S. Markley, John L Miller, Karen L. Prescott, Allyn L. Ricketts, Donald G. Scandrol, Georgia J. Scarff, Ruth Ellen L. Simmons, Oden R. Warman, Ida D. Williams, Jerry D. Williams, and David D. Wilson Jr.

At a memorial service, the Conference honored the memories of one active clergy member, Bishop’s Assistant Robert W. Higginbotham; 13 retired clergy, 26 clergy spouses, and eight lay members.

Mission and Outreach

Conference members packed 44,670 meals for Stop Hunger Now and filled a truck with an estimated 30,500 pairs of old shoes to aid the Erie United Methodist Alliance’s homeless ministries and All God’s Children/Ramps to Hope ministries to those with disabilities. The shoes bring funds for the missions  based on a per pound rate from Funds2Org. The shoes are kept out of landfills and and Funds2Org delivers them to micro-enterprise ventures in developing nations.

Members also brought 2,277 kits for UMCOR to the Mission Barn drop-off, including 1,346 health kits, 459 school kits, 234 birthing kits, 96 cleaning buckets, 85 sewing kits, 48 layettes, and 9 bedding kits.

During the Conference, the East German Partnership celebrated its 25th anniversary and the Rev. Werner Philipp, an ordained elder from the East German Annual Conference spoke to the conference and offered a prayer in German.

Awards and Presentations

Paul Morelli, the new chair of the Conference Evangelism Team, recognized the 2014 recipients of the Denman Awards for evangelism.  Thomas  Verner received the award for youth, Michelle Polohonki received the award for adult laity and Randall Bain received the award for clergy. Three Conference evangelists were approved by the annual conference: Rev. John Zimmerman as full-time general evangelist and Luella Krieger and Christine Rogan, part-time.

The Golden Sneaker Award for miles logged in walking programs with a spiritual dimension (or alternative activity), was presented to the Washington District. Erie-Meadville earned the Silver Water Bottle Award and the Indiana District received the Bronze Award for third place. This was the last year for the Golden Sneaker Awards.

During a youth presentation, the Pineapple Award for support of the Youth Ministry Team activities was presented to Sandra Matoushaya, Zimbabwe Partnership Coordinator. The Timothy Award for a student who models the characteristics of 1 Timothy 4:11-12 went to Kevin Jenkins of Chippewa UMC.

Four young adults -- Angel Stahlman, Katie Wrona, Paul Koblosky,and  Jillian Schweigart—shared their stories of receiving a call to ministry.

Patti Columbe, CEO, and Deryl Larsen,secretary,of the Keystone United Methodist Federal Credit Union board, presented a check for $4,000 to Bishop Bickerton to assist in the Conference’s ongoing ministry. That brings the total amount given by KUMFCU to assist with new church starts to $63,000.


Conference members approved a connectional apportionment budget for 2015 of $9.78 million, an increase of less than 1 percent over the 2014 apportionment budget of $9.69 million. The total Conference budget for 2015, including income from endowments and other sources, is $34.63 million.

Members also approved legislation:
  • Calling on the Pennsylvania General Assembly to develop legislation that provides the Dept. or Corrections with guidance regarding the use of solitary confinement and limits the amount of time a person may be held in solitary confinement;
  • supporting Pa House Bill 1005, the Juvenile Justice Act,which would allow for re-sentencing of individuals who were sentence to long prison terms or life without parole for crimes committed when they were under age 18 and change other mandated sentencing practices;
  • Providing a Change of Appointment Leave for clergy being moved to a new church or charge. It would begin two weeks before the start of the new appointment;
  • Setting the basic cash compensation for clergy serving full-time at $39,160 for elders, $37,960 for associate members, $35,699 for provisional members, and $35,169 for local pastors. 

Several pieces of legislation were not approved, including:
  • a proposal to move the site of annual conference to Indiana University of Pennsylvania,
  • a call for creation of a divestment task force in the conference 
  • a petition calling for deletion of the sentence in Paragraph 161 F of the Book of Discipline declaring homosexuality as incompatible with Christian teaching, and 
  • a proposal to encourage local churches to study gun violence against children. After amending the title of the resolution, the action ultimately failed to pass by a vote of 391 in favor of the resolution and 393 against.
In other Conference business, Larry Bridge was elected as the new Conference Treasurer.

A total of 1501 individuals, including members, vendors and visitors, attended the conference session. 

To see photos, video and the Daily Journal, go to AC2014/news